Now nobody will ever know what happened to her.
This is a list of unexplained theories about characters. Though most of the happenings are caused for Black Comedy, it leaves unexplained answers.
Cuddles
- In the Cuddles Smoochie, Cuddles appears to be allergic to carrots (he eats one then suffocates), but in A Bit of a Pickle, he is seen with carrots in his grocery bag. However, it has not been revealed as to whether or not he is allergic. Perhaps Cuddles died from choking on the carrot and not from an allergic reaction.
Giggles
- Her broken leg in Helping Helps is unexplained.
- Her lack of a tail raises questions. Some speculate she lost it as a result of an accident.
Toothy
- In Mime and Mime Again, he is in the hospital in a body cast, though it is unknown how he got injured. His tail is also missing (probably cut off during the accident).
- In The Carpal Tunnel of Love, Toothy is allergic to bee stings (he is stung in the eye and it becomes swollen). However in Aw Shucks!, he gets stung by a swarm and did not have an allergic reaction. Perhaps those were wasps instead?
- It is unknown how Toothy got the evil book in Read 'em and Weep or if he knew it was evil. He may have got the book the same way he did with the Cursed Idol.
Lumpy
- It is unknown how Lumpy gets his jobs, considering his low intelligence.
- It is unknown how he got his left antler upside down. It is possible that this happened to him because of an accident, or because he was born that way already.
- In Every Litter Bit Hurts, he had hooves. Later in Wipe Out, he has toes.
- In Concrete Solution, Lumpy has blue eyes. Later in Wishy Washy, his eyes are green. Although he's dead when his eyes are green so this may be because he died in sewer water.
- In Snow Place to Go, it is unknown where he went when he walked away.
Petunia
What happened to Handy's hands?
- It is unknown whether or not she died in House Warming.
- She may have a crush on Mime.
Handy
- It is unknown how Handy lost his arms. Also, it is unknown how other characters regenerate their body parts while Handy's arms remain amputated, this is like Russel's injuries, which also don't regenerate.
Splendid
- He seems to have been created as a tribute to Superman.
- His origins are unknown, though it seems more of an alien origin.
Flaky
The last thing Flaky ever saw on that island.
- Her unseen death in Happy Trails part 2: Jumping the Shark remains a mystery. There are many theories about how she was killed, or whether she was killed or not. It is likely Flippy could have been her killer or helped to get her killed.
- Her gender was previously a big debate among fans until it was confirmed in 2012 that she was indeed female.
Nutty
- It is unknown why he is seen at a butcher shop in A Change of Heart when he is normally seen at a candy store. It's probable that Nutty is trying to get rid of his addiction as he realized it's taking control of his life or it's possible that he was just on a diet.
- Nutty has a small brain in Easy Comb, Easy Go. Later in Swelter Skelter, his brain is larger.
Flippy
This all happened in less than 3 seconds.
- Flippy's whole carnage in By The Seat Of Your Pants is completely inconsistent. Lumpy spent only three seconds underwater, yet Flippy managed to kill the audience, along with an elephant and a car driver. That would be a death too quick even for Flippy to return to his place.
- Considering the blood on the ground near the vehicle's tires, it can be said that a car crash happened along with Flippy's carnage (but the fact of Flippy causing it is very unlikely). That would imply that the truck driver, who is responsible for the deaths of Toothy, Nutty, and Truffles, could have been either Nutty or Truffles as they weren't there at first. So it's likely that while Flippy killed Sniffles, Giggles, and Flaky (despite her distance from him) and injured Handy, a car crash occurred at the same time where a car was sent flying and threw Nutty in the water, beheaded Truffles, and ran over Toothy.
- On a lesser note, where did the elephant come from?
- If Flippy did cause the car crash or the deaths of Truffles, Nutty, and Toothy. Then maybe, he's faster than the speed of light? Or it's what he's capable of doing in mere seconds?
- It is quite possible that Flippy was Flaky's killer in Happy Trails Pt. 2: Jumping the Shark as Handy couldn't have killed Flaky without hands, Lumpy wouldn't even know what he was doing, and Sniffles has never killed anyone on purpose before, so this kill leaves Flippy responsible. Then again, Handy seems to be able to do pretty much anything hands-related as long as it's offscreen, Lumpy has shown occasional moments of competence, and Sniffles tries to kill The Ants all the time.
The Mole
- The cause of The Mole's blindness is unknown.
- It is unknown how The Mole gets his jobs, considering his blindness.
- The Mole's face (apart from his nose and mole) has never been revealed. However, in Pet Peeve, when his face is crushed by a piece of glass, his skull is visible, and it was discovered that he has buckteeth, like most of the characters.
Disco Bear
- In Easy Comb, Easy Go, Disco Bear was still able to see The Mole cutting his hair even after slicing off his own eyes with a straight razor.
Russell
- Similar to Handy's, He has unexplained amputated legs, a damaged eye, and a hook. As with Handy, he did not regenerate his lost body parts like most characters do.
- In the episode "Snow Place to Go", Russell wasn't captaining the ship even though he clearly has more experience than Lumpy. He also didn't captain the ship in Idol Curiosity, but instead was mopping the deck.
- It is unknown why Russell has shoes seen in Sea What I Found even though his legs are amputated.
Mime
- He may not actually be mute since he is able to make noises (choking sounds, horn honking noises, etc.), implying that he can talk but just chooses not to.
- However, it is unknown how Mime does not scream at all even when is in extreme pain.
- He may have a crush on Petunia.
Lifty & Shifty
- It's unknown where exactly they live.
- How the two are able to steal large amounts of items is unclear; a possible lack of security could be the answer.
Sniffles
- Sniffles keeps trying to eat the same group of ants, even after all the torture they put him through.
- It is unknown what happened to Prehistoric Sniffles. Perhaps he died along with the dinosaurs, became frozen like Cro-Marmot, or was killed by ants.
- Rumours have speculated that Sniffles ate the father ant, hence the Ant Family's sadistic hatred against him.
- In Blast from the Past, Sniffles ate an ant in front of Prehistoric Sniffles. Then, Prehistoric Sniffles ate an ant that it was on his shoulder (and they were probably friends), so it's said that Sniffles started the Anteaters-Ants vendetta.
Pop & Cub
- It is unknown what happened to Pop's wife/Cub's mother.
Cro-Marmot
- How does Cro-Marmot move and do things when he is frozen?
- It is unknown whether or not he died in Concrete Solution, and Wrath of Con.
- It's unknown how is it possible that his block of ice doesn't melt.
Lammy & Mr. Pickles
- It is speculated by most people that Mr. Pickles is a mere figment of Lammy's imagination, though it is unknown how he can change locations. Also, in Royal Flush, Mr. Pickles was able to kill Flaky without Lammy being involved, which further fuels the possibility that he is a living thing.
- It is debated by some that Lammy and Mr. Pickles could be French due to their appearances.
- As shown in A Bit of a Pickle, Lammy has a crack in her skull; it's unknown how it got there.
Truffles
- Truffles has not been technically introduced (aside from cameos), so his character is unknown. Though judging by his clothing, he may be a sailor. Images of him also show that he may be grumpy, rude, or spoiled.
- As of now, it is unknown what Mondo will do with Truffles. It is possible he may be introduced as a character in a starring or featuring role of a future episode.
Miscellaneous
- It is unknown how characters reincarnate after death (apart from the fact that they are in a cartoon). Some hints may be provided in Blast from the Past and Better Off Bread, when Sniffles and Splendid respectively reversed time to fix flaws. It is possible that their time warps are responsible, as the merry-go-round scene from Spin Fun Knowin' Ya is seen in the former.
- Why do cemeteries exist in a universe where characters can reincarnate after death?
- The age group of most characters (with exceptions for Pop, Cub, Lumpy, Handy, Splendid, Cro-Marmot, Flippy, and Disco Bear) seems to change in various episodes. Many characters have been portrayed as kids, teenagers, or adults in different episodes.
- The Giant Squid appearing inside a house in Doggone It raises questions.
- It is unknown what happened to the father of the Ant family. Theories say he could have died from war, died from old age, or was eaten by Sniffles prior to the show.
- Characters' homes change throughout the series, especially Lumpy's home where in some episodes he is seen living in a trailer, but on other episodes he lives in an entirely different home.
- It is currently unknown whether or not humans do/did exist in the HTF world. However, there is proof that they might had.
- In By The Seat Of Your Pants, nobody seemed at the least bit shocked that Lumpy's lower torso was missing skin. Sniffles should have at least noticed, and Flippy could have flipped out from that.
- It is unknown how the tree house in House Warming caught fire. Some think another character who was unseen did it, or it could have been caused by a serious heat wave.