Toothy's Tortoise is a possibly reoccurring animal character in the series. It mainly appears as Toothy's pet in Junk in the Trunk. In Letter Late than Never, a similar-looking tortoise (possibly the same one) is also seen, but this time the creature is very violent. It attacked Lumpy the mailman and chased after him various times. The tortoise was shown to be very determined, as it did not give up pursuing Lumpy until it finally caught and devoured him whole. There is a chance that it is a different animal than the first, due to the inconsistent behaviour. The terrapin appears again in A Sight for Sore Eyes in Lumpy's closet as a rather Lumpy choice of seeing-eye animal, only without the flame design.